RUSCHKA MASOET reports on the issue of illegal vending at traffic intersections in the Newlands area and considers the softer side of the ethical debate.
Vending at traffic intersections is an issue that affects motorists in Cape Town on a daily basis. While vendors might flout the law, they do show entrepreneurial spirit in spite of much adversity.
Vending within five metres of traffic intersections is criminalised in terms of the National Road Traffic Act, however several traffic intersections are known as vending ‘hot-spots’, used by as many as ten traders at times.
The intersection of Paradise Road and the M3 at Newlands Avenue is one such ‘hot-spot’. Despite clear signs designating the junction as a no-trading zone, vendors ply items ranging from cell phone chargers and rugby paraphernalia to original works of art.
Ward Councillor for the area, Ian Iversen stated that illegal vending at the Paradise Road intersection was not particular to that area, but occurred throughout South Africa as a direct result of the economic situation in the country.
Iversen emphasised that vendors occupied the intersection because people were willing to buy things from them, ‘…the bottom line is that traders occupy the Paradise Road site because motorists purchase their goods. If they stopped supporting them then the traders would disappear!’
While acknowledging that vendors were simply trying to ‘eke out a living’, Iversen noted that even police raids were not successful in deterring the vendors who ‘leave the area for at best a day before they return.’
‘The law is there for a reason and I cannot understand why it isn’t enforced… the police try from time to time to clear the area but hours later they appear again,’ commented Sally Hannath, who lived near the intersection for ten years and formed part of the security team in the area.
Michael Dhlamini, aged 30, is a qualified electrician who depends on the profits from the sale of his beaded artwork to support himself and his family in Zimbabwe. Having moved to Cape Town because of the political situation in his home country, Dhlamini has spent four of his twelve years in Cape Town selling art along the M3.
After becoming despondent about finding work as an electrician, Dhlamini decided to sell art, ‘I am selling because I cannot find work here because of my papers. There’s nothing, the people have kindness but if you don’t have citizenship or asylum it’s hard… I gave up looking for work,’ said Dhlamini. Recounting the consequences of a police raid at the site, Dhlamini said, ‘The police always take our stuff every time, it’s difficult. They take our stuff, they check our papers and sometimes they take you, they lock you up Fridays and only release you on Monday.’
These vendors are in a situation where the need to produce an income overrides the risk involved in breaking the law. Is this show of entrepreneurial spirit not worth commending? Perhaps we should legalise vending at traffic intersections so that there can be a measure of control and regulation over trade in the area. After all, the vendors are not begging or resorting to crime, but simply trying to earn a living.